Higher Education Doesn't Have a Software Evaluation Problem. It Has a Decision-Making Problem.
Selling technology into higher education is not for the faint-hearted.
Multiple stakeholders. Complex approval processes. Uncertain budgets. Lengthy RFPs. Endless demonstrations. And pilots that sometimes seem to have no expiry date.
Sound familiar?
For EdTech vendors, particularly those delivering mission-critical systems such as Student Information Systems (SIS), the sales cycle can stretch well beyond 12 months — sometimes considerably longer.
But here's the uncomfortable question:
Are institutions evaluating software to make a decision, or using the evaluation process to avoid making one?
Due diligence is essential. Indecision isn't.
Let's be clear. Replacing an SIS is a significant undertaking.
It impacts students, faculty, administrators, finance, compliance and virtually every aspect of institutional operations.
Institutions should absolutely undertake rigorous evaluations.
But there's a difference between managing risk and creating a procurement process so complicated that making a decision becomes the greatest challenge.
The hidden cost of prolonged procurement
Consider what happens during an extended evaluation:
Vendors invest heavily in RFP responses, demonstrations, workshops, technical assessments and solution design, often with little visibility of the likelihood of a purchase.
Institutional staff spend hundreds of hours attending meetings, reviewing proposals and debating requirements.
Existing systems continue ageing, often requiring additional maintenance, workarounds and investment.
Innovation gets delayed, while students and staff continue working with technology the institution has already identified as inadequate.
Requirements keep changing, potentially sending the evaluation process back to the beginning.
And perhaps most importantly, the longer the process continues, the harder it can become to maintain momentum and stakeholder alignment.
The pilot that never ends
Pilots and proof-of-concepts have an important role.
They should answer specific questions, validate critical capabilities and reduce uncertainty.
But a pilot without agreed success criteria, an accountable decision-maker and a defined completion date isn't really a pilot.
It's an extended evaluation with no commitment to a decision.
And that creates costs for both the institution and the vendor.
What should change?
Perhaps it's time to rethink how higher education institutions procure technology.
Not by compromising due diligence, but by making it more focused.
1. Establish the budget before approaching vendors.
A procurement exercise without realistic funding creates unnecessary work for everyone.
2. Identify who owns the decision.
Stakeholder consultation is important, but consensus shouldn't mean everyone has an unlimited veto.
3. Evaluate outcomes, not endless feature checklists.
Focus on what the institution needs to achieve, rather than attempting to document every possible scenario.
4. Set clear evaluation milestones.
Define the criteria, timeline and decision process upfront. If a pilot is required, agree on what constitutes success.
5. Respect the commercial investment required from vendors.
A competitive procurement process should be rigorous, transparent and proportionate. Vendors shouldn't be expected to provide unlimited consulting and solution design without a credible purchasing pathway.
Indecision is a risk too.
At RIO Education, we understand why institutions take SIS selection seriously. They should.
But we also believe the industry needs to have a more open conversation about the cost of prolonged procurement.
Every additional month spent evaluating is another month an institution isn't realising the benefits of its intended transformation.
And while institutions are rightly concerned about choosing the wrong solution, they should also consider the consequences of not choosing at all.
The best procurement process isn't the longest or most complicated.
It's the one that provides enough evidence to make an informed decision, with confidence, within a reasonable timeframe.
Because indecision has a cost too.
And it's rarely included in the business case.
What do you think? Has higher education procurement become unnecessarily complicated, or is the extended evaluation process justified by the risks involved?
